For Book Clubs and Libraries

A short book for discussion, and a guide drawn from the text.

Groups

A discount for book clubs

If a group of five or more would like copies of Life Is Fair: Why Fairness Depends on Where You Stand, a 20 to 30 percent discount off the list price is available. The author is also glad to join a meeting by video for a short conversation, at no cost, if that would help.

Libraries that would like to consider the book for a collection are welcome to get in touch. A donated or review copy can be arranged.

Write to hello@euamedia.com to ask about a group discount, a review copy, or a visit. The discussion guide below is free to use.

List price and purchase links will be added when the book is listed for sale.

Discussion guide

Life Is Fair: Why Fairness Depends on Where You Stand

A guide for book clubs, drawn from the book. The four central characters — Ruby, Henry, Eli, and Keza — and their scenes are invented; the research cited in the book is real. Questions are keyed to chapters rather than to individual page numbers.

  1. The book opens with one claim: “what is fair depends on where you stand. The same event can look just to one person and unjust to another, and both can be sincere.” Do you accept that claim? Can two sincere people disagree about fairness without one of them being wrong? (Chapter 1, “A Note Before You Begin”)

  2. In the prologue, Luis loses ten dollars — the gas money that would have got him to work before payday — and Grant loses a thousand dollars on a canceled trip. The book asks, “So. Whose loss was bigger?” and then, “If you answered right away, ask yourself how you knew.” What did you answer, and what did that answer reveal about where you were standing? (Chapter 1, “Prologue: Ten Dollars and a Thousand”)

  3. Dana hears the true story of Marcus’s promotion and still tells a friend, “Well, it helps to know the right people.” Marcus, hearing that Dana’s mother helped with a house, closes his mind in the same way, without learning that Dana had spent years paying her mother’s medical bills. The book says nobody in these scenes was stupid, and nobody was lying. When have you discounted a true story because you had already decided what it meant? (Chapter 1, “Jealousy: Dana and Marcus”)

  4. At eight, Ruby, Henry, Eli, and Keza sit at the same lunch table with very different meals and very different views of the world: a free-lunch card held low, a lunchbox with initials on the lid, a metal container of home food, a warm sweet potato. The author says you will meet them again at eighteen, twenty-eight, thirty-eight, and seventy-eight, and that “no one in these pages is a hero or a villain.” Which child did you side with first, and did that change as the book went on? (Chapter 1, “Three Children, Age Eight: Lunch”)

  5. Chapter 2 is titled “Everybody Struggles.” At eighteen, each of the four is asked, “What are you going to do now?” and the question never means the same thing twice. Do you think everyone struggles in a way that can be compared, or are some struggles so different in kind that the book’s title overreaches? (Chapter 2)

  6. The book gives each person a private “pain gauge” — a dial that measures what a blow costs — and later a “satisfaction gauge” that measures when “enough” arrives. It says the two are not simply opposites: “A person can have little pain and little satisfaction at once, and a person can have a lot of both.” Does that match people you know? (Chapters 2 and 5)

  7. In Chapter 3, Ruby, now at a desk job, hears a coworker order a fourteen-dollar salad and immediately converts the price into “an hour and forty minutes of her old shifts.” Henry, at a charity dinner, is told he “must feel so grateful,” and finds that gratitude does not make the weight lighter, “only harder to mention.” How does hardship — or the absence of it — change what a person is allowed to say out loud? (Chapter 3, “Twenty-Eight”)

  8. Chapter 4, “The Box We Can’t See,” finds them at thirty-eight: Eli in the warmest room he knows, Ruby working two jobs after a divorce she has no time to explain, Henry in a treatment circle where no one recognizes him. The book is interested in the beliefs that set without our noticing. What “box” do you live in, and what would it take to see it from the outside? (Chapter 4)

  9. In “Ten Thousand Dollars, Four Times,” the same sum arrives in each of their lives on the same Tuesday. “Same ten thousand dollars. In one life it filled the gauge to the top and left it ringing. In another it barely moved the needle.” Why does the identical reward read so differently, and what does that do to our habit of judging other people’s choices? (Chapter 5)

  10. Chapter 6 moves to an unnamed village in an unnamed country, where late rains, a visitor, and a festival honor make the same point in a different register: comparison is local. “The Joneses” are whoever is standing next to you. After reading that chapter, who are your Joneses, and what happens when you stop using them as a ruler? (Chapter 6, “The Village Has a Gauge Too”)

  11. Chapter 7 opens, “Laila, Eli’s wife, had done everything right.” She kept the house, the faith, and the family calendar — and then a phone call in an ordinary kitchen interrupts that sense of order. The chapter asks “Why me?” and “Does it even out?” and looks honestly at how people reach for karma or a reason. Do you think a life evens out? If not, is the book’s later turn toward contentment a genuine remedy, or a way of dodging injustice? (Chapter 7, “Does It Even Out?”)

  12. At seventy-eight, in “The Long View,” the four can finally see the shape of what they have lived. The book does not declare a winner. Near the end it offers contentment as one practice among others: “Contentment starts by putting the ruler down. It does not ask you to stop wanting things, or to stop noticing what is unfair. It asks you to stop letting the Joneses set your needle.” And then: “If you take one thing away, take this. Life is fair, because everyone has a level of struggle and a level of happiness. No one is spared the first, and no one is shut out of the second.” Do you leave the book more willing to believe that, or less? What would “putting the ruler down” look like in your own life? (Chapter 8)

A closing note, if the group wants one

The author’s own last request is small. He cannot promise that anyone will see through another person’s eyes. “But you can stop assuming that a different view is a wrong one, and that’s enough to begin.” The Author’s Note adds that this is not a book that tells you whether life is fair. It is about why the answer looks so different depending on where you stand, “and why the balance of a life can be read only from inside it.”

Optional: if the author is joining by video, you might ask him where he was standing when he wrote the title — and whether the title is a conclusion, or a dare.